The engine is humming and the green flag will be raised soon
June 29, 2007
The INDY 500 race begins every year with the green flag being waved to the 33 drivers who will attempt to complete the race under what are frequently harsh conditions (this year’s race was cut short by bad weather). In interest rate land we use the green flag to indicate an all clear signal to our readers that rates are headed lower. The yellow flag is used in conjunction with our forecast when we are in a cautious mode while waiting for rates to peak. On March 23rd of this year we raised the yellow flag with the 10-year at a level of 4.61% and that has saved our readers 42 basis points as the 10-year closed today at 5.03%. With the end of 1st half of the year we wave good bye to the strong seasonal pressures for rates to rise and welcome the seasonal trend to lower rates in the 2nd half of the year. Although we are not quite ready to move the green flag in front of the yellow flag, the stage is set for another drop in long-term rates as we enter the July/August period. In the last 41 years we have seen long-term rates drop 31 times for an average move down of 141 basis points. Whether we see a drop to 3.62% this year will be determined by the economic landscape but we enter this period with the odds in favor of a drop to at least the 4.50% level.
The tote board
Much like the odds at a race track that flash the chances (determined by the bettors) of a horse winning each race, the interest rate forecasting business is made up of the millions of borrowers and lenders who come to an agreement each day on an interest rate for the 10-year Treasury note (5.03%). Most forecasts today are for a continuation of the current Fed Funds rate at 5.25%. After early year forecasts of lower rates most experts have now thrown in the towel and feel that the Fed will stay on hold for the remainder of 2007 and 2008. History is often used to forecast the future and in reviewing the past 17 years of Fed policy (somewhat similar economic environment) we see that the average number of months between a Fed policy change is 12 months with a range of 5 (1995) to 17 (1994). The Fed went on hold in 6/06 and now has gone 12 months without any change and might set a new record if recent forecasts prove accurate. BUT we must remember that most of this history comes from the Greenspan era and each chairman has placed his own signature on the Fed so history may not be a good barometer this cycle.
The Fed
Thursday’s FOMC meeting produced nothing unexpected as Chairman Bernanke led his team in another chorus of “the song remains the same” with a Funds rate at 5.25%. The Fed continues to focus on an inflation rate of 2% or slightly under and is concerned about oil over $70 and food prices that have been rising all year. Corn is down 20% in the last two weeks, but soybeans and wheat rose to yearly highs as acreage was switched to corn. The key ingredients for a change in Fed policy revolve around the stock market, unemployment rate and loan demand. Unfortunately none of these have moved much in the past few weeks but that could easily change depending upon the continued meltdown of the mortgage market. Over the past 40 years I have witnessed the Fed make a 180 degree change in policy in reaction to a significant economic event that impaired liquidity in the marketplace. If we are to see that event this year it would certainly come from the forced “market to market” of sub-prime debt owned by funds that operate on very high leverage. The best I see from this sector over the next six months is a “muddle through” but the most likely is more of the same where debt owners are forced to liquidate and that brings up the age old question: “Sell to whom?”
The economy is growing but very slowly
There has been much written about inflation fears by the Fed and price increases being passed through to the consumer. Real rates of interest have risen in the past few weeks as expectations of a strong 2nd quarter GDP have created worries in the bond market that inflation may reappear later this year. If inflation were a real threat would we have seen the recent 54 bp increase (March 13 until today) in the 10-year be dominated by the inflation component and that has risen only 4bp. If inflation was threatening wouldn’t we see someone on strike from our 135 million work force? (Not one labor strike in the US in June.) If the economy was growing would we see Southwest Airlines announce a cutback in capital spending for 2008 by several hundred million dollars? If inflation was growing wouldn’t it be easier for gas stations to pass on cost increases to the buyer, especially for a product that is inelastic like gasoline? (Inelastic is when demand does not fall when prices rise.) Quote of the week (thanks DC) comes from Maine where the owner of a gas station told us: “Last year, credit card companies made more on a gallon of gas than the retailers.” Prices are increasing but margins are dwindling to nothing for many businesses as consumers spend more on one item at the expense of foregoing another item. Inflation stats will continue to decline for the next six months especially since rental rates are dropping due to homeowners that have come to the conclusion that a rental payment is better than a foreclosure. Finally we saw this week that the American Trucking Association reported another decline (1.3%) in truck tonnage in May after April’s decline of 2.2%. 75% of goods sold to consumers in the US are transported by truck and we expect this to have an negative impact on retail sales later this year as retailers order smaller deliveries as their customers cut back on spending.
House prices are falling and office space is available
This week we saw that house prices fell again last month but what the stats don’t show are the sales at high prices with huge sales incentives for the buyer. In Loretto Bay (near Las Vegas) we see a home builder offering zero payments for either 12 or 18 months and zero money down. This is a great incentive but an overpriced house is still overpriced unless you are planning on moving within the first couple of years and have a guaranteed buyer when you are ready to leave. From the Sacramento area comes news that we haven’t seen for many years, a glut of office space. The one branch everyone was hanging on was that the commercial area was holding up well and many of the displaced residential workers could find jobs in commercial construction. It appears that a few branches are about to break and the tree will have a few hard years ahead.
China laying off risk to its citizens?
A very important story in the June 27th Xinhua News (China) tells us that the Ministry of Finance has authorized a bond issue to be offered to Chinese citizens. The proceeds ($200 billion) will be used to purchase US dollars that are currently stored for a rainy day by the Chinese National Bank. The world has watched as “hot” money has been used to sell dollars and buy the undervalued Chinese currency (Yuan). The Chinese central bank has accumulated 1.2 trillion dollars of foreign exchange reserves and has decided to spread the risk of a declining dollar to its citizens. The State Council will suspend the interest tax on personal savings to give everyone an incentive to purchase these bonds. The Chinese government is attempting to slow down the heavy rush of funds into its stock market and probably allowing the government to purchase more dollars as it continues to keep the Yuan from appreciating at a more rapid pace.
Scoreboard and predictions
In my initial 2007 EWW (see archives) I forecast three surprises for the year and the first was one of the worst calls I have made in many years. Sugar not only did NOT rise 40% in the first six months but actually fell 15% to its current level. “Never buy something that is given away for free” became the battle cry for sugar bears as supply from Brazil overwhelmed the market every month of this year. The stock market did take a sharp fall in late February/early March but came right back in June to reach new highs. Finally I said that the housing debacle would be much worse than everyone had predicted and that has turned out correct with more to come. Overall grade a “C” so let’s try for a better grade in the last half of this year.
Scorpios are stubborn and I am no exception so I will go back to Sugar for my first call. If oil continues to stay near the $70 level the demand for sugar used for ethanol will increase and that should send the price back up at least 25%. The stock market is being held up by stock buybacks, takeovers and the powerful “yen carry” trade so it will probably take a rise in the yen for the stock market to see any meaningful depreciation. My forecast of a long, slow, painful bear market for residential real estate is intact and I see a short period of strength over the summer for values but back to the slow decline during the fall and winter months.
Interest rates
Most of my day is spent studying and reviewing events that could effect future interest rate movements. For the next six months I have the following probabilities: 65% – the most probable path is for long-term rates (currently 5.03%) to drop to at least the 4.50% level but only after a retest of the 5.32% area we saw three weeks ago. A slowing economy led by a drop in consumer spending and low inflation will ignite demand for US bonds but due to problems in the mortgage area we may not see the same drop in residential borrowing rates. I would only punt on this forecast if we saw the 10-year rise to the 5.50% level for at least two weeks. 25% – a replay of the 1987 story where the stock market melts down due to a shortage of liquidity in the mortgage market and its bleeds through to the economy and forces the Fed to intervene by increasing reserves to banks. This is probably the reason we have seen a move to a positive yield curve in the past few weeks as someone is making a large bet that history is about to repeat. The key to this occurrence will come from the action in the long end of the yield curve. If the 30-year interest rate drops more than the 2-year we are more likely to have scenario #1 but if the short end leads the long end down scenario #2 will take the market for the next few months. 10% or less – I am completely wrong and inflation picks up without the Fed showing any concern and the 10-year rises to 5.50% and stays there or above. I actually have a hard time putting a 10% probability on this but you never know in this business and stranger things have happened over the last 40 years.
Conclusion
We have arrived at the starting line for the most favorable interest period of the year. Although loan demand has stayed strong and the stock market is near its recent highs we should be in a position for long rates to begin a sharp drop to much lower levels. Inflationary expectations are contained and the most recent run up in Treasury yields came from a fear that growth in the economy would translate into future inflation and I just don’t see that in 2007. We will know sooner than later and hopefully my 40-year old crystal ball has a few good years remaining. Remember that “fear” stands for “false expectations about reality” and my forecast is that the interest rate market will soon reconcile reality and recent false expectations with lower rates.
This is NOT an investment newsletter and I advise all readers to consult with a professional investment adviser before entering any markets with their hard earned dollars.
