Don’t Lose Sight of the Big Picture
March 31, 2008
The next few months will bring a bounce to the US economy and stock market; it will NOT represent the end of the credit contraction and lower real estate values. The recently passed Washington stimulus plan will soon kick in with $100 billion+ in checks from the IRS to hit bank accounts and mailboxes across the US in a few weeks. Whether consumers pay down debt, use for savings or spend on new items the end result will be a temporary boost for the economy and GDP. Hurricane Katrina (2005) brought a much smaller spike in consumer spending to the South and I am expecting something similar in duration but greater in its affect on the US economy. Recent stock market activity shows a growing resilience to bad news and soon the market will rally as those betting on further declines will learn that being early can be very painful. Counter trend rallies are always difficult as they trap those hoping and wishing for a return to the good old days.
If the current rules cause too much pain……change the rules
Last Friday the Securities and Exchange Commission sent an interesting memo to certain public companies regarding regulations dealing with valuation of assets for financial statements. These companies are required by SFAS 157 to value their securities holdings to fair market value based on the availability of market prices. Level One assets are usually those that have daily or weekly closing prices on an exchange or something similar. Level Two assets are those where the value can be calculated by reviewing the prices of similar traded assets or formulas. Level Three assets require a “guesstimate” because a lack of liquidity can create a distortion in the price of transactions. With billions of dollars of write-downs in the past year required by company auditors these firms have seen their earnings plummet and stock prices have followed to new lows. Of course the old rules did not require companies to “mark to market” any drop in value and assume that each security would be held to maturity when full face value would be realized. With liquidity at a premium for everything except US Treasuries and the cost of raising capital increasing each week, the SEC is giving some companies the option to go back to the old rules. They are now allowing corporations to “use valuation models that allow significant unobservable inputs for some of your assets and liabilities.” The key words in that sentence are “significant unobservable” which can be translated to just about whatever you need if the loss is bigger than you want it to be. It is hard enough understanding a public company’s financials and trust is a HUGE factor in becoming a shareholder. Do you actually believe a company will announce its quarterly earnings with a note that its level three assets have been artificially boosted by millions or cents per share based on someone inside the company changing the value of a company asset? This could set a very dangerous precedent as once the opportunity is available to “certain” public companies the remainder will want to access the same loophole. Yes, the auditors are probably requiring their clients to take conservative marks with their portfolio but if left to the company itself aren’t we inviting a runaway freight train that eventually is certain to crash? Isn’t that what happened to Bear Stearns?
The Fed is focused on liquidity but the real problem is asset deflation
The past six months have seen the beginning of the worst credit contraction this country has seen in over 70 years. The ability to sell or borrow against an asset is an integral part of the US economy and is one of the reasons we have been able to grow rapidly with little inflation over the past 25 years. The Fed has used its main tool of overnight interest rates (Fed Funds) to lower the cost of credit to borrowers this year and hope eventually it will lead to an increase in loan availability. The longer term issue that it will soon be faced with comes from declining asset prices. Currently the consensus is that we are in a temporary pull back in real estate prices with this opinion coming from a hope that past experiences will be repeated in the next few years. Every dip in prices over the past 30 years has been a great buying opportunity for those brave enough to step up at the first sign of distress from sellers. Unfortunately the past is not about to repeat in the same way and after this upcoming bounce we will head lower and cause tremendous “fear” for those that have tried to catch the falling knife of lower prices. A credit contraction is defined by loans being extinguished faster than new ones are created thus giving cash the greatest return each year. Falling prices increase the value of debt (especially Treasuries) and put extreme pressure on those in debt who need values to rise and overcome high interest payments. Credit contractions are almost always accompanied by declining price levels and a rush to deleverage which is what we are seeing in the residential housing market.
The good news is that we have a Fed Chairman who has studied economic history with a focus on the deflationary periods many countries have witnessed over the past 400 years. On November 21, 2002 Mr. Bernanke gave a speech titled: Deflation: Making Sure it doesn’t happen here” and it is MUST reading for all of my readers. Please take the time to read this at least a few times and you will get a sense that the Fed head is as prepared as one can be for the oncoming storm. The medicine needed to survive isn’t easy and takes awhile to execute but you will feel much better after reading this historic speech. He understands that the level of long-term interest rates is one of the keys to stimulating consumer spending and reviews the many alternatives available to the Fed including placing a ceiling on long-term rates and/or the purchase of private (non-government securities). These remedies will only be used if we see negative GDP numbers and rising unemployment (next jobs number 4/04).
Lenders without capital
A credit contraction can only be ended by the creation of new loans. Capital is the key to any lender as it must have reserves for every loan it issues and lenders are very short on capital due to write-downs on real estate loans. This afternoon Lehman Brothers announced a 3 million share offering of convertible preferred stock and it appears that investor demand was very high. What I find interesting is that investors are lining up to purchase a security where the dividend rate, conversion rate and other terms are yet to be determined according to the press release. Would you be a buyer of a security without knowing any of the terms? Very strange and one has to wonder why Lehman rushed to make the announcement without any of the important details.
Bernanke speaks to Congress
Wednesday morning (4/02) the Fed head testifies before the Joint Economic Committee of Congress at 6:30am. He will be asked about Bear Stearns, the economy’s health, the mortgage mess and the future. He should take this opportunity to hit one out of the park (today was opening day for the MLB) and become a confident leader that we need from our Fed Chairman. No one knows economic history (I’m not close) like Ben Bernanke and the country and world need to hear his thoughts and most importantly preparations for what is certain to be the toughest time most of us have ever experienced. Change is difficult for everyone but losing in company rather than having the courage to win alone is not the answer to surviving in 2008-09.

